Pope Benedict XV’s peace plan aimed to halt the widespread destruction and loss of life by proposing balanced terms that could be accepted by all belligerents without humiliation or resentment. His proposal contained several key elements:
- Reduction of Armaments: Benedict urged nations to mutually reduce their military arsenals, aiming to prevent future conflicts by limiting the capabilities for aggression.
- Arbitration and Mediation: He called for the creation of international institutions and treaties that would handle conflicts through arbitration rather than warfare.
- Self-determination and Territorial Integrity: The Pope emphasized respect for national self-determination and the rights of nations, advocating for territorial disputes to be settled through negotiation rather than conquest.
- Freedom of the Seas: Benedict proposed that the seas remain open to all nations, promoting international trade and cooperation.
- Renunciation of Reparations: He strongly argued against imposing harsh reparations, asserting that punitive economic demands would only breed further resentment and instability.
Similarly, the Central Powers - led by Germany and Austria-Hungary - found Benedict’s proposals challenging, as their strategic aims included extensive territorial gains, which conflicted directly with the Pope's emphasis on territorial integrity and national sovereignty.
Critics of Benedict XV’s peace proposal raised several objections. Chief among these was the notion that his approach was overly naive, assuming that mutual goodwill could quickly replace entrenched hostilities. Opponents argued that the Pope failed to acknowledge the deep grievances and profound animosities that had accumulated during the war, making a return to pre-war conditions practically impossible. Moreover, secular governments and nationalist groups viewed Benedict’s mediation as intrusive, resenting what they saw as ecclesiastical interference in secular political affairs.
Nevertheless, Benedict XV’s peace plan holds historical significance as an early attempt at multilateral peacekeeping and diplomacy. His ideas presaged later diplomatic efforts such as President Woodrow Wilson’s Fourteen Points and the eventual founding of the League of Nations. While his immediate efforts may have fallen short, Pope Benedict XV’s vision for international reconciliation laid crucial moral and intellectual groundwork for future peace initiatives.