Mimetic teaching and learning

A comprehensive essay on what it means and looks like to teach and learn mimetically, specifically in the context of teaching and learning in a classical education environment.

Teaching and learning mimetically in classical education

Introduction

Classical education, deeply rooted in the traditions of the Greco-Roman world, aims to cultivate wisdom and virtue through rigorous study and character formation. Within this educational framework, the concept of mimetic learning - learning by imitation - is central, offering a unique approach to the acquisition of knowledge, the shaping of virtue, and the refinement of skills. Mimetic learning stands in contrast to the more contemporary emphasis on innovation and self-discovery, focusing instead on emulating great works, models, and instructors. This essay explores the concept of mimetic learning, examining its roots in classical pedagogy, its implementation in classical education, and the impact it has on both teachers and students.

Understanding mimetic learning

Mimetic learning, derived from the Greek word mimesis, means imitation or emulation. This educational approach asserts that students best learn and internalize skills, virtues, and knowledge by imitating the works and behaviors of masters. Mimetic learning takes as its foundation the understanding that certain ideals - whether in art, literature, science, or character - are worth striving toward and that students benefit from the wisdom of those who have come before them. Rather than focusing on constructing knowledge from scratch, students in a mimetic framework adopt an initial posture of humility, recognizing their need for guidance and modeling.

Mimetic learning relies on three principles: modeling, imitation, and assimilation:

1. Modeling: Instructors and sources of study provide concrete examples of excellence, from historical figures to timeless literary works.
2. Imitation: Students actively attempt to replicate the style, approach, or thought processes of these models, learning through practice and engagement.
3. Assimilation: Over time, through repeated imitation, students internalize and personalize what they have learned, eventually making it their own.

In a classical education setting, mimetic learning is thus more than rote memorization; it is a deep engagement with works and practices that have been proven valuable over generations.

Mimetic teaching in classical education

In classical education, the teacher is not only a conveyor of information but also a model for intellectual and moral formation. The role of the teacher in a mimetic framework is both directive and participatory. Rather than simply presenting information, teachers embody the values and habits they wish to instill. They demonstrate a disciplined approach to reading, thinking, and questioning, encouraging students to follow suit. Mimetic teaching is rooted in mentorship, where the teacher’s example becomes a living curriculum.

1. Modeling classical virtues
In classical education, teaching virtues like temperance, courage, wisdom, and justice is integral to the curriculum. Teachers who embrace mimetic methods do so by first exemplifying these virtues themselves, showing students what it means to live virtuously rather than merely describing it. For instance, a teacher might demonstrate intellectual courage by respectfully engaging with challenging material, encouraging students to do the same without fear. This modeling forms a natural bridge between theory and practice, inviting students to mirror the behaviors they observe.

2. Providing exemplary works
The classical curriculum places a high value on canonical texts and works of art that reflect ideals of beauty, truth, and goodness. These works serve as models for students, inviting them to imitate the styles, ideas, and values they embody. Reading Shakespeare, for example, is more than an exercise in language and plot; it is an opportunity for students to imitate the eloquence, moral complexity, and keen insight into human nature that characterize his works. Teachers encourage students to read, write, and think in dialogue with these models, gradually cultivating a refined and informed intellect.

3. Structured imitation through practice
Mimetic teaching in classical education also involves structured exercises in imitation. Students may be asked to copy famous passages, write in the style of a classical author, or practice the argumentation of historical figures. In subjects like rhetoric, for example, students might study the speeches of Cicero, then attempt to craft their own orations following his methods and techniques. This practice fosters discipline, attention to detail, and an appreciation for the craft of writing and speaking.

Mimetic learning for students

In mimetic learning, students take on the role of apprentices, learning by emulating models rather than by attempting to forge new paths prematurely. This mode of learning cultivates patience and discipline as students work toward mastery. Mimetic learning in classical education is thus both rigorous and holistic, shaping not only the intellect but also the character.

1. Imitating great thinkers and writers
Mimetic learning in classical education frequently involves engagement with the thoughts and styles of great thinkers, including Aristotle, Aquinas, and Shakespeare. Through the imitation of these intellectual giants, students learn to think deeply and develop clarity in expressing ideas. When a student tries to write in the balanced, rhetorical style of Cicero or to reason through a philosophical question with the systematic rigor of Aquinas, they internalize methods of thinking that transcend the exercise itself. This process encourages humility, as students recognize their place within a tradition of knowledge and inquiry that predates them.

2. Practicing virtues through emulation
Classical education aspires to shape both the mind and character. Mimetic learning aids this goal by allowing students to practice virtues through repeated imitation. For instance, through the consistent study of virtuous figures in history and literature, students are encouraged to adopt similar virtues in their lives. Studying Socrates’ commitment to truth and justice inspires students to value truthfulness, while reading about the humility and perseverance of figures like Saint Augustine challenges them to develop similar virtues.

3. The role of repetition and refinement
Mimetic learning emphasizes the importance of repetition in mastery. Just as classical musicians perfect their craft through practice, classical students refine their intellect through repeated exposure to and engagement with the same works and ideas. By working through Euclid’s proofs or reciting passages from Homer, students build an enduring foundation of knowledge and skills. Repetition is not seen as redundancy but as a process of honing understanding, where each encounter with a work or concept reveals new depth and insight.

The transformative power of mimetic learning

Mimetic learning is transformative because it combines intellectual and moral formation. By imitating the best of human thought and character, students learn to approach life with a sense of wonder and responsibility, understanding that they are part of a broader cultural and intellectual inheritance. As students advance, they gradually develop their unique insights and ideas, informed by the models they have studied.

Moreover, this learning approach fosters community. By studying the same works and following the same practices, students form bonds with one another, as well as with the authors and thinkers they encounter. This shared pursuit of wisdom and virtue fosters a sense of solidarity and respect, enriching the learning experience.

Conclusion

Teaching and learning mimetically in a classical education environment is an endeavor rooted in reverence for tradition, excellence, and moral integrity. It embraces the wisdom of past generations and sees value in modeling and imitating exemplary works and individuals. For teachers, mimetic education means embodying the values and skills they wish to impart, leading by example, and providing students with models worth imitating. For students, mimetic learning is a journey of growth and self-discovery that deepens their understanding and shapes their character.

By adopting a mimetic approach, classical education emphasizes that wisdom and virtue are cultivated not in isolation but in the context of a rich intellectual heritage. This process not only prepares students to think critically and act virtuously but also instills a profound respect for the cultural inheritance they are privileged to engage with. Through mimetic learning, the classical education system creates not only scholars but also individuals of character who appreciate the interconnectedness of knowledge, tradition, and virtue.